Sunday, February 25, 2007

a study in contradictions

I am simultaneously one of the most cynical and idealistic people I know. How is this possible? I don't know, but for example:

I know that I will not change the world in a drastic way so as to eliminate poverty (or something similar), but I can not stop myself from trying.

I am resigned to the fact that DearlyBeloved will probably never decide to check the dishwasher to see if it empty before placing his dirty dishes in the sink, but I still remind him to look.

I think groups in Christianity have gone nucking futs lately (and I have been known to crack a few jokes about the conservative evangelical right-- sorry) but I still believe there is something beautiful about it, especially when I meet certain people.

I thought John Kerry was a well-intentioned but very ineffective rich moderate, but I still worked as part of his campaign staff.

I went to school and the result was a strange blend of theology, philosophy, justice and peace studies, and business... and I never really decided how exactly they could be combined as a paid profession, but I am extremely efficient when it comes to finances.

Sometimes I wonder if, when I volunteer, I'm really doing it for myself so that I'll feel like a good person. Because I like to feel like a good person.

I really want to go to law school but I'm not sure if I want to be a lawyer. "Good thing you're not paying for it." Yeah, I know.

Are you simultaneously cynical and idealistic in areas of your life?

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

I often wonder the same thing about volunteering. We all like to feel good about ourselves. But although you may be doing it for somewhat selfish reasons, it does not take away from the fact that you are intentionally (or untintentionally) helping others.

1234 said...

I guess it comes down to whether or not we believe that there is such a thing as a truly good deed.

I mean, if we volunteer but absolutely hate it, we're still fulfilling some sort of need for ourselves to "do the right thing." So it's still self-motivated; it may not make us feel good, but it lets us feel ok with ourselves.

Maybe we can take solace in the fact that we want to do the right thing. Still selfish, perhaps, but there's no way to avoid it.

Benjamin said...

I am cynical about every good intention and just cause and yet I work at a non-profit that runs on good intentions and just-causes. Thus, my contradiction.

And I really don't think that we need to worry about some sort of Kantian notion of the "good" being only that which is stripped of emotion and affection and done purely out of some notion of strict and perfect duty. That is nonsense. We give ourselves so that we can not only show appreciation to the other but be appreciated ourselves as well.

Anonymous said...

Hey meow, know how u feel! As u know, I studied political science and am spezialising in strategic studies and war studies...my newest crazy idea is to become a warjournalist...just went from crazy to nuts, I guess, because I know that I cannot change the world and humans are capable of very bad things, but still wanna see...and tell.
Your Swiss sister